Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jim Davidson's avatar

One of the important characteristics of warfare is the lack of consent. As I wrote in "Paladin's Rules," the absence of consent is the key indicator of crime. Warfare is crime in all cases. The term "war crime" is redundant, pleonastic, and repetitive. The objective of warfare is to obtain through coercion what cannot be obtained by discussion. And why should the more physically or militarily dominant side prevail if they don't have adequate arguments to support their preferences?

The answers to such questions don't arise from understanding the generations of warfare. So I won't bother to quibble with your divisions - quite a few military historians would separate formation warfare from the first generation and assign it to the second; redefine third as combined arms running from the 18th through the early 20th Centuries ending with ww2; and start 4th generation with the sorts of asymmetric war we found in Vietnam. But such quibbling ignores my basic point, which is that war is criminal. That it is regarded by nation states as acceptable is an indictment of nation states.

The spiritual response to warfare and other crime arises from a deep understanding of the Holy Spirit, God the Father Almighty, and the words of Jesus Christ. There are abundant reasons why Jesus says, "he that hath a purse, let him take it, and likewise his scrip: and he that hath no sword, let him sell his garment, and buy one." For we must be prepared to defend ourselves with both economic and physical means, both scrip and sword, against those who would enslave us. God loves free will, He made so much of it.

Let us pray: Eternal Father, please help us to free the slaves, stop the wars, and end tyranny. Please help with guidance, resources, ingenuity, endurance, fortitude, and patience. Please show us the little fires so we may pass by them. Please bring love into our lives so we remember what we have to live for. Amen. Mother Mary please intercede with your powerful intercession. Amen.

Expand full comment
onecloud's avatar

and what pray tell, would be the generations of peacemaking?

Expand full comment
31 more comments...

No posts